VZtwit

Video Exposes Police Abuse in Venezuela (Or is it Mexico? Or Colombia?)

Posted on February 25, 2014 by Madeleine Bair

By Madeleine Bair and Vienna Maglio

One video’s journey across Latin American protest movements underscores the challenge of monitoring activism online. 

Last Friday, the end of a week in which mass protests in Venezuela resulted in hundreds of arrests and five deaths, a new YouTube video circulated among Venezuelan social media networks showing police officers spraying a water cannon at a young man tied to a tree.  The title described in Spanish the GNB—part of Venezuela’s armed forces—torturing a student in Táchira, a state along the Colombian border where clashes have been especially violent.

The problem was, the Human Rights Channel had seen this video before. The same footage circulated among Colombian activists early this year.

The YouTube description of this version states that the video was uploaded from a mobile phone on December 29, 2013. Colombian media activists reported on the video, describing it as depicting ESMAD, or Colombian special forces, torturing a farmer who participated in the country’s widespread agrarian protests.

And there’s more. Using Google’s reverse image search, we found another use of the video, uploaded a month later, with the title, “Mexican police torture civil defence groups.”

Media Manipulation Distracts from Authentic Footage

While it’s unclear who would scrape, re-upload and intentionally misidentify footage of police abuse and with what motivations, it is easier to imagine why so many activists, believing the footage to be true, would share the video among their networks. (On Sunday night, the video was removed by the uploader, after several commenters pointed out that it was scraped from a different context.) After all, the mistreatment of detained activists had been reported on by reputable sources; and considering the attacks on journalists covering the protests, citizen reporting and social media have become critical tools to document and share news of the protests and abuse of authorities. But as Global Voices has reported, both opposition activists and media channels supporting President Nicolás Maduro have engaged in the dissemination of false, decontextualized, or misleading images.

One widely circulated Facebook thread condemned the alleged use of photos from Syria by anti-government protesters in Venezuela.

One widely circulated Facebook thread condemned the alleged use of photos from Syria by anti-government protesters in Venezuela.

The distribution of false images with hidden agendas not only fuels the political—and increasingly violent—divide, but makes it difficult for those monitoring the movement online to separate fact from fiction.  And it places an extra burden on those trying to document the protests honestly.

This is why verification is at the core of the Human Rights Channel, which works with our partners at Storyful to make sure that we not only amplify authentic footage of human rights abuse, but put a stop to the spread of misinformation.

(Of course, fighting false rumors is only one challenge facing media activists in Venezuela. Many photos and videos of the protest movement may never see the light of day due to the reported confiscation of cell phones of detained activists and journalists.)

Resources for Filming and Finding Authentic Footage

For those documenting the protests in Venezuela or elsewhere, following a few basic steps when uploading videos will help third parties verify that your footage is authentic. See here for a downloadable tip sheet on effectively uploading to YouTube. A few key pointers include:

  • Title: Keep it brief and descriptive, including the date and location.
  • Describe: In the YouTube description, include greater context about the video, such as what happened before, during, and afterwards, and links to more information.
  • Credit: If the video was originally uploaded by a different user or on a different website, provide a link to the original video. That will help journalists or human rights monitors verify that the footage is authentic.

For those monitoring the protests online, and curating images documenting abuse, the Verification Handbook is a free online resource with tools and tips to determine the authenticity of online media. For a downloadable Spanish tip sheet on how to verify online video, click here. You can also subscribe to the Human Rights Channel on YouTube and follow us on Twitter for the latest on citizen video of human rights abuse.

What Others Are Saying

  1. Anima April 30, 2014 at 4:33 am

    Oh yeah? Stupid? On so many lelves? On so many lelves you couldn’t mention one? I suppose it’s about as stupid as thinking a three-day old embryo is fully protected by the Constitution.Duane

  2. Paul Bailey March 25, 2014 at 1:08 pm

    We’ve got the links to the Writ of Habeas just delivered to the court, please download and share the links, we want people to know what Frisco, Texas Police Department does when they realize they made multiple mistakes!

  3. Jesus Robles Maloof February 25, 2014 at 6:41 pm

    Great work you guys. I have seen this video in Mexico a lot. Qe have to pay more attention. Nice work!

    • Madeleine February 26, 2014 at 6:25 pm

      Did you really see it in Mexico? Interesting to know, and thanks for the feedback!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>